Burger & Botha Recieve Bans

_45983774_burger_botha282gi
Bakkies Botha and Schalk Burger have both been banned following incidents in the 2nd Test this weekend. Burger, who was found guilty of gouging by a citing tribunal received 8 weeks, while Botha who was found guilty of dangerous charging cops a 2 week ban.

Burger who was spotted using fingers in the eye area of Lions wing Luke Fitzgerald within the 1st minute of Saturday's game was yellow carded at the time following a recommendation to Christophe Berdos from assistant referee Bryce Lawrence. The 2nd Test marked Burger's 50th cap and a return to rugby after 8 weeks sidelined with injury.

Botha's charge left Lions prop Adam Jones with a dislocated shoulder and unfortunately ended his involvement with the tour. Steve Hinds, the IRB citing comissioner, flagged both incidents and passed them on to Alan Hudson the IRB judicial officer. Fitzgerald gave evidence at the hearing and was supported by Lions lawyer, Richard Smith.

While the bans rule both players out of the third test, Burger will also miss the opening three matches of this years Tri-Nations. Within the team camps, the perception surrounding the gouging incident couldn't be more converse. Ian McGeechan's view was clear, "It should be automatically a red card as I understand it. To me that it is never part of the game, I could never condone actions like that."

Springbok coach Peter De Villiers however didn't agree, "I don't believe it was a card at all. In the first minute already there had been a lot of needle and if you watch the whole game you will see how many yellow cards they were let off. This is sport, this is what it's about. If things were clear-cut then we shouldn't even bother preparing for a game. Everyone is entitled to their opinion."

Responding to De Villiers comments, McGeechan said: "I am very disappointed if that's what he said because for me you can't see that and say it's a part of the game that I would ever want to be associated with."

0 Comments

Hines Banned for One Week

NathanHinesLionsPA
Following a citing by judicial officer Alan Hudson, Nathan Hines has been banned for one-week. The Scot made a tackle on Wilhelm Steenkamp in the 9th minute of last nights match against the Emerging Springboks and while it went unpunished by match referee Alain Rolland, the citing commissioner decided that the incident warranted further review.

Hines has 24 hours to appeal the ban, but if he does not, or a challenge is unsuccessful, he will now miss the second test in Pretoria.

0 Comments

Hines Cited For Dangerous Tackle

NathanHinesPALions
Nathan Hines has been cited for an allegedly dangerous tackle on his opposite number Wilhelm Steenkamp during last nights draw against the Emerging Springboks. The citing official picked up on the incident after it went unpunished by referee Alain Rolland.

Hines is the first player to be cited during the tour and will face judicial officer Alan Hudson in Cape Town where a decision will be made. Hines is in with a shout of a second test berth - along with all the other Lions locks - and a ban at this point would certainly end those chances.

We'll have further news on this incident as it develops.
0 Comments

Quinlan Out, Croft In

TomCroft_1191552
Alan Quinlan will not tour with the British & Irish Lions this summer after an appeal to overturn his 3 month ban was rejected.

The Munster flanker, a surprise inclusion in the original squad was cited and subsequently received a 12 week ban for a gouging incident against Leo Cullen in the Heineken Cup semi-final on May 2nd.

Leicester back-row Tom Croft has been chosen by Ian McGeechan to replace the Irishman. Tour Manager Gerald Davies this evening made the announcement stating that:
"Alan Quinlan's suspension is naturally disappointing and he must be devastated by the outcome of the hearing and appeal. That said the Lions management fully accepts the decisions of the ERC judicial process. The outcome necessitated the selection of a new player and Ian McGeechan and his fellow selectors had no hesitation in selecting Leicester's Tom Croft."

Asked to comment further on the selection of Croft, McGeechan added: "We had to be fair and allow Alan Quinlan the opportunity to appeal his suspension. However, following the outcome of the appeal we have replaced Quinlan with Tom Croft who, it must be said, was very unlucky not to have been selected in the original tour party."

"Tom showed in his recent performances for Leicester following the tour party announcement that he could put aside his disappointment and perform at a very high level. He was on our selection reserve list and today his continued good form has been rewarded with selection to the Lions squad for the tour of South Africa."

0 Comments

Alan Quinlan Banned for 12 Weeks

AlanQuinlan
Alan Quinlan has been banned by a citing committee judging his case and will miss the British & Irish Lions tour to South Africa.

The incident, which occurred in Munster’s Heineken Cup semi loss to Leinster on May 2nd involved Quinlan’s fingers making contact with Leo Cullen’s eye area. Gouging is considered extremely seriously by citing committee’s and the 12 week ban is the minimum allowable in the event of a guilty verdict.

The independent Disciplinary Committee chaired by Roger Morris (Wales) and also comprising Simon Thomas (Wales) and Mike Hamlin (England), found Mr Quinlan guilty of foul play in contravention of Law 10.4 (k) in that he had made contact with the eye area of Leinster player Leo Cullen. Both parties have the right to appeal within 72hrs.

Speaking to BBC Sport, Munster manager Shaun Payne expressed Quinlan’s feelings following the verdict;
"Obviously this was going to be the pinnacle of Quinny's career, he is absolutely distraught and very very disappointed, and I think any person who enjoys rugby will know what that means to him."

Mike Blair was announced on Monday as the replacement for the injured Tómas O’Leary, but as of yet the Lions coaching and management team have yet to name a replacement for Quinlan. We’ll be covering this story as it develops.
0 Comments

Quinlan Waits on Fate

AlanQuinlan
Alan Quinlan will face a disciplinary panel trio this afternoon to decide his Lions fate following an apparent incident of gouging in Munster’s Heineken Cup semi-final loss to Leinster on 2nd May.

The hearing will be chaired in Dublin and is due to start at 1300 BST. Independent commissioner John Byett chose to cite the incident and as the offense carries a minimum 12 week ban a guilty verdict is near certain to rule Quinlan out of the tour. We will have coverage of the outcome as soon as it is know.
0 Comments

Quinlan Hearing Date Set

After a considerable wait, Alan Quinlan’s citing hearing has been scheduled. The Munster back-rower will face a citing panel on Wednesday to decide his fate. If he is banned he can expect at least 12 weeks on the sidelines and will miss the Lions tour.

Recent similar incidents involving Neil Best and Dylan Hartley have seen bans of 18 weeks and 6 months handed out respectively.
0 Comments

Quinlan Citing To Be Delayed?

Alan Quinlan may be set for a wait before finding out whether or not he is to tour with the British and Irish Lions this summer. Following his citing for making contact with Leo Cullen’s eye-area in last weekend’s Heineken Cup semi-final, the Munster back-row is a doubt pending a disciplinary hearing.

It is thought that the hearing may not take place until May 13th as the European Rugby governing body will require some time to organise a panel.

In other news, Leicester and England fly-half Toby flood is out for six months after rupturing his achilles in the nail-biting game against Cardiff on Sunday. He will play no part in England’s summer tours and given the relative fragility of the Lions squad in the fly-half position, any hope of him joining the tour as a late replacement is now dashed.
0 Comments

Quinlan Cited

headshot_quinlan
Following Alan Quinlan’s contact with Leo Cullan’s eye-area during Saturday’s Heineken Cup semi-final he is now likely to miss out on his Lions dream. Although he has not yet appeared before a disciplinary panel, if found guilty he can expect a minimum of 12 weeks suspension.

John Byett, the independent citing commissioner decided a citing was in order after the video replay clearly shows Quinlan making contact with the fingers. He will appear before the citing panel ‘as soon as practicable’ and if he is handed a ban, which seems likely at this stage, he will lose his Lions place.

Both his captain and coach stood up for his character following the match against Leinster. "Quinny isn't that type of guy," said Paul O'Connell. "He is a tough player. It is the one thing he hasn't got in his record book. If it looked bad, I am sure there was nothing in it."
0 Comments

Quinlan Waits on Citing

headshot_quinlan
Munster’s Alan Quinlan, a surprise inclusion in the Lions touring party has a nervous wait on his hands following a possible citing incident in his teams defeat against Leinster this weekend. The back-rower was clearly seen to make contact with Leo Cullen’s right eye and worryingly, based on the TV footage it appeared that he seemed to dig his fingers in.

Gouging is typically dealt with very seriously indeed. Lengthy bans are typically only ever exceeded by drug related offences like those handed out to Matt Stevens and Australian Wendel Sailor. Earlier this season Northampton’s Neil Best was banned for 18-weeks for a similar offence. It goes without saying that if he is cited and found guilty, his touring dreams will be over. If that is the case, Tom Croft is likely to be the first number in Ian McGeechan’s phone.

Croft has already been talked up by the Lions management as a player who was very unlucky not to make the cut, and we’ll be keeping you up to date with developments regarding this story.
0 Comments
This image is a theme.plist hack